
Back in 2005 when Stanford first rolled out with their iTunes initiative, it was hailed as a great step towards openness in education. I remembering downloading lectures and listening to them during the workday. Some were good, some were not so good. Many of the materials were focused on alumni and of little interest to the general listener. The less “campus-life” and more academic lectures seemed haphazardly selected and poorly organized. There were no complete courses. All-in-all I was unimpressed by the site and didn’t see why it was compared with MIT and other more developed OCWs.
Two years down the line, the site has developed quite a bit, little resembling how it started. Let’s take a closer look.
Number and Variety of Courses Offered: B
One of the biggest changes on the site is the introduction of courses. Although there are only 13 currently available, they are good selections on interesting topics and appealing to a wide base of users. For instance, “Historical Jesus”, “Virgil’s Aeneid” and “Straight Talk About Stem Cells” could as easily appear on the iPod of my aunt as my old thesis advisor.
Furthermore, the limited number of courses doesn’t communicate the quantity of materials available. By browsing through the “Categories” index to the left of the homepage, you can see all of the audio available under topics such as “Law and Politics” or “Health and Medicine”. These categories list courses but also group materials together under areas of study, making it easy for a user to find relevant audio and video. Also listed are materials by featured contributors (mainly institutes within the university).
I’m really impressed by the quantity and variety of materials on the Stanford iTunes site. While not too many full courses are currently available, I’d expect to see more and more appearing soon. If not for this lack of full courses, Stanford would certainly get an “A” in this category.
Course Substance: B+
With so much material on the site, there’s bound to be some stuff better than others. As regards the actual courses, I found the ones I’ve listened to the be quite weighty and substantive while also easy to understand without being an expert on the topics. For instance, although “Hannibal”only has 7 lectures, each is between an hour and one-half to two hours and full of content. Other courses such as “The Literature of Crisis” has 20 tracks of the same length and “Modern Theoretical Physics” has 17 videos (iPod ready) between two semesters.
Meanwhile, the hodgepodge of lectures organised by topic is a goldmine when it comes to content. Head to International Relations > International Security and you’ll find 31 lectures ranging from “Children in Combat” to “The CIA and It’s Secret War in Tibet”. Institutes such as the Stanford Health Library offers 59 lectures such as “Why Zebras Don’t Get Ulcers”.
Once again, I’d love to offer a better grade, but this materials is not enough to really simulate being in the classroom. Sure, there’s lots of good stuff on here, but other than the handfull of courses there’s not too much really focused on one topic. And although the courses are really great (don’t get me wrong), 7 lectures or so doesn’t approximate a full semester of studies.
Material Mix & Accessibility: C+
Sadly, this is the area where Stanford most suffers. Although the iTunes platform makes it easy to download and enjoy the audio/video on your iPod, the material is, unfortunately, very tailored to iPod use. Although some materials have some brief pdf lists of recommended materials (eg, the Benjamin Franklin course), there are no textbooks or accompanying readings.
Overall Score: B
I think that Stanford probably deserves a better grade than “B”. They certainly get an “A” for effort - the site is light years beyond where it was when it started. But the site is very much “stuff to put on your iPod” and not so much “open coursewares simulating university courses”.
The university is moving in the right direction and can only improve. My recommendations to them: move beyond the iTunes platform, create a companion website with space for comments and interaction and open textbooks. Go for the “A” and the gold ring - you can do it!
Next week we’ll be talking about Berkeley - there’s just so much material on it that I need a little more time to do it justice.