There is a perception among users that all search engines are similar in function, deliver similar result and index all available content on the web. Librarians, on the other hand, understand the differences.
The goal of a metasearch engine is to mitigate the inherent difference of single source search engines, thereby providing Web searchers with the best search results from the Web’s best search engines!
In an overlap research study conducted by Dogpile.com in collaboration with Queensland University of Technology and Pennsylvania State University, which measured the overlap of first page search results from Google, Yahoo! LIve and Ask, found that only 0.6 percent of 777,435 first page search results were the same across these Web search engines.
The top four search engines further diverged in terms of search results:
+ 88.3 percent of total results were unique to one search engine.
+ 8.9 percent of total results were shared by any two search engines.
+ 2.2 percent percent of total results were shared by three search engines.
+ 0.6 percent of total results were shared by the top four search engines.
Full report: Different Engines, Different Results: Web Searchers Not Always Finding What They Are Looking For Online - Research Study 2007.